Saturday, October 18, 2014

Flows from Bronx 14

Congrats to all who broke. 

These are light on commentary because of what happened last year with Tab.  This year I split it between ballots and comments on the flow.  I'm looking at some beautiful round 3 ballots for a kid who didn't break and scratching my head about the disconnection.  

I on the other hand tend to accentuate the negative.  It's more useful to you, I hope.

Here's Chamber 4 in Session 1:



Here's Chamber 3 in Session 3:



Sunday, August 3, 2014

The Script

Here's a link to the script introducing Congressional Debate and other materials from the CFDI presentation on 8/3/14.

Please feel free to make use of any of it.

What is Congressional Debate?

Choosing a Bill Topic

The Script

Policy Analysis Chart:

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Here's NSDA 2014: Nats Flow-Ballots



More ballot comments than flows, especially for House 8.  Sorry if I seem a little testy on those.  As always, my comments are purely intended to help.  Ruthlessly disregard anything that isn't helpful.  My motto in all things:  It's probably better than nothing.

Congrats to everyone who made it to NSDA Nats 2014.

Senate:  Bitcoins
Senate:  Ban Arms Sales to Iraq
Senate:  Renegotiate NAFTA

House:  Space Societies
House:  Sahel
House:  Civil Unions
House:  Minimum Wage

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

NSDA Nats flow-ballots . . .

. . . will appear here when Sen. Klein and Rep. Rucci are done with competing and I'm done with judging, so either tonight (I hope not) or tomorrow night (I hope).

In the meantime, eat your veggies and cite your sources, everybody.

Will the tournament apologize for putting two House chambers in a room?  I certainly hope so if it hasn't done so already.  My pref sheet should have been distributed with two tabs of Adderall and close captioning.  (Actually, that's probably just a good idea in general.)

All Instagram captions of this unfortunate choice should honor our Wizard of Oz setting:  "Pay no attention to that House behind the curtain!"




Monday, April 28, 2014

TOC 14

Generally really great work everyone.  Everyone in the room clearly deserved clearly to be there.

Argument flow and comments on top with general comments at bottom.  Please just treat these as if they were non-interactive.

As always, take what you can from these.  If you disagree with anything I wrote, you're probably right.  (But give me a little credit for trying?)

To get them out close to when you get the rest of your ballots, I am publishing without proofreading.  Enjoy the inevitable typos.

Top 8 Round by Round
Morning Hour and PO RFD
Electricity
Chemical Facilities
Treaty-Rama
Patents
Hate Crimes
ESA
DDT
DC
FDA




Saturday, April 5, 2014

Great Midwestern Novice Nats Flow-Ballots: Updated with working links!

Don't be overwhelmed.  Instead of flows by speaker, the arguments are arranged by type.  You made the arguments beside your initials.  At the bottom of the spreadsheet, you'll see ballot-type comments in speaker order left-to-right.

If you think I'm wrong about something, it's probably true.  This is the best I could do.  

Good job, generally, overall.  My biggest complaint was that people didn't prep, even on the easy-to-prep bills like Minimum Wage (a high priority for the Dems) and Tax Reform (a major initiative met with a lukewarm embrace by both parties).  A half-hour per bill would have been enough to get anyone into Supers, I'd bet.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

OK, here they are. Harvard Prelims and Semis Parli Flows and Comments

The usual caveats apply--these are snapshots of my thinking as each debate unfolded with some feedback I hope will be helpful.  They're at least a little better than nothing, I hope.  In some cases I make the arguments I'd make against yours.  (Usually anything starting with "But" is a response I'd make.)

If you're sure I'm wrong about something, let's just agree that I probably am.


Semis Chamber A

Pretty good rounds all the way through.  At this year's Harvard tournament I learned these things: 
  • Snappy, dramatic, and even scenery-chewing delivery is a key skill for many judges (but it's not for me).  A few of the finalists would make great silent film actors.
  • Very few people pay attention to my earnest pleas and dire threats about using complete sources (name, qualification of source, publication name, and date).  But some do try to adjust.  And there were only a few instances where I thought something sounded sketchy and no instances at all where I was completely certain I was being lied to.  
  •  I've lost patience for half-baked legislation.  The best bills closely follow existing real-world proposals.  Outside of congress, I'm pro-imagination.  But I'm against imaginative bill writing.  Don't use your imagination!  Bills are homework for everyone, and bad bills are just cruel, cruel, cruel.  If you can't find at least one expert who directly says that your plan exactly will solve the problem, you need to find another topic (for everyone's sake).  
  • People generally are getting better at Congress, and that's causing the event to mature and become more challenging.  About ten years ago, PF was immature.  Around that time I judged a PF semis round at TOC where one team had only a single piece of evidence!  Congress has matured from clash-free parallel oratories to an actual debate event to a sometimes rigorous debate event.  I hope we can keep that up.  Congress really is the best.